Understand Your X-Ray

DR MICHAEL LOH / Understand Your X-ray

UNDERSTAND YOUR X-RAY

A Knee X-Ray Can Tell You More Than You Think

A knee X-ray is not just a picture of your bones.

When properly taken and professionally interpreted, an X-ray can help us understand changes in the knee joint, including:

  • Joint-space narrowing
  • Bone spurs (osteophytes)
  • Knee alignment
  • Bone and joint deformity
  • Other structural changes associated with osteoarthritis

But there is one important point:

The severity seen on an X-ray does not always match the severity of your pain.

Some people may have significant X-ray changes but relatively little pain. Others may experience considerable pain even when the X-ray changes appear less severe.

That is why an X-ray should be considered together with your:

Symptoms + Clinical Examination + Functional Ability

Understand Your X-ray

What Should You Look For on a Knee X-Ray?

1. Joint Space

Look at the space between the thigh bone (femur) and shin bone (tibia).

This joint space can provide an indirect indication of the condition of the cartilage and other structures within the joint, including the meniscus.

As osteoarthritis progresses, the joint space may become narrower.

Generally:

Relatively preserved joint space → Narrowing → Severe narrowing

An important point to remember:

X-rays do not directly show cartilage.

What we see is the joint space, which is one of the important radiographic features used to assess structural changes in the knee.

2. Bone Spurs — Osteophytes

You may notice small bony projections around the edges of the joint.

These are called osteophytes, commonly known as bone spurs.

They are a common feature of osteoarthritis and may develop as the joint undergoes degenerative changes.

The number and size of osteophytes are among the features doctors consider when assessing knee osteoarthritis.

3. Changes in the Bone

As osteoarthritis progresses, changes can also occur in the bone beneath the cartilage.

An X-ray may show features such as:

  • Increased bone density beneath the joint surface, known as subchondral sclerosis
  • Cyst-like changes
  • Changes in the shape of the joint surface
  • More obvious structural changes in advanced disease

These findings can provide additional information about the condition of the knee.

Knee health educational illustration

4. Knee Alignment

We also look at the overall alignment of the leg.

Some people develop:

Varus alignment — Bow-legged

or

Valgus alignment — Knock-kneed

Changes in alignment can affect how body weight is distributed across the knee and may place greater stress on certain areas of the joint.

Knee health educational illustration

5. Is There Subluxation or Deformity?

In more advanced osteoarthritis, the normal relationship between the bones may change.

Your doctor may assess for:

  • Subluxation, where the joint surfaces are partially displaced from their normal relationship
  • Loss of normal alignment
  • Bone deformity
  • Changes in the contour of the joint surface

These findings can be particularly important when assessing more advanced knee degeneration.

Knee health educational illustration

How Severe Is Your Knee OA?

One commonly used system for grading knee osteoarthritis on X-ray is the:

Kellgren–Lawrence (KL) Classification

Knee health educational illustration

KL grading describes X-ray changes. It is not a direct measurement of how much pain you should experience.

Not All X-Rays Are the Same

This is often overlooked.

For knee osteoarthritis, the way an X-ray is taken matters.

For example, a standing, weight-bearing X-ray can show the knee under load.

Depending on the clinical situation, different X-ray views may also be needed to assess different parts of the knee.

Your doctor may compare:

Right knee vs Left knee

and, when appropriate:

Before treatment vs Follow-up X-ray

Why Compare X-Rays?

A single X-ray gives us a snapshot in time.

Comparing X-rays taken at different times allows us to observe changes over time.

Depending on the clinical situation, doctors may compare:

  • Joint-space appearance
  • Knee alignment
  • Osteophytes
  • Bone changes
  • Overall joint structure

In my practice, repeat standing, weight-bearing knee X-rays are a required part of the planned follow-up protocol. The timing is discussed individually. This describes my practice’s approach; imaging plans may differ between clinicians and patients.

For selected patients, MRI may provide additional detail about cartilage, the meniscus, ligaments and other tissues. When there is a useful clinical question to answer, we discuss its value, limitations and cost. For patients who choose to proceed and can afford it, MRI may form part of assessment or follow-up.

An X-ray should never be used on its own to determine whether a treatment has worked.

Symptoms, physical examination and knee function remain important.

Before & After: What Can We Learn?

Real, anonymised patient X-rays can be useful for understanding how doctors compare images.

BEFORE → FOLLOW-UP

A comparison can highlight changes in:

  • Joint-space appearance
  • Alignment
  • Osteophytes
  • Other visible structural features

The purpose is not simply to show a “better-looking” X-ray.

It is to ask:

What has actually changed, and what might those changes mean?

Where appropriate, X-ray findings can be considered alongside the patient's:

Pain → Mobility → Function → Daily Activities

Clinical Observation

Interestingly, in some patients in my clinical practice, I have observed follow-up standing, weight-bearing X-rays where the joint space appeared wider, some bone spurs appeared smaller or less prominent, and certain previously visible bone spurs were no longer clearly seen.

These are observations from individual patients. They need to be interpreted alongside symptoms, examination and progress over time. A single case or X-ray comparison cannot establish that the same result will occur in every patient.

X-ray appearances can also be affected by knee positioning, bending or rotation, weight distribution and the angle of the X-ray beam. Comparisons should use consistent imaging techniques wherever possible. Images alone cannot establish exactly which tissues have changed or whether a particular treatment caused the difference.

EA Clinic case 03: before and follow-up weight-bearing X-rays of a left knee, with dates and reported clinical KL assessments
Figure 3. Before and follow-up weight-bearing knee X-rays.

The grades shown reflect the treating clinician’s reported assessment of this individual case. They require review of the original, comparable images and do not establish reversal of OA or predict another patient’s outcome.

X-ray changes can also be affected by positioning, weight-bearing status and imaging technique. Before-and-after comparisons are therefore best made using comparable X-ray views and interpreted by a qualified medical professional.

There Is More to Your X-Ray Than “Bone-on-Bone”

When you hear terms such as:

“Bone spurs.”

“Severe OA.”

“KL Grade 4.”

“Bone-on-bone.”

Don't immediately assume that surgery is your only option.

First understand:

What does the X-ray actually show?

And equally importantly:

What does it not show?

Surgery may still be appropriate when symptoms and disability substantially affect your life and non-surgical care is ineffective or unsuitable. The decision should consider your overall assessment and preferences.

Your X-Ray Is Only One Piece of the Puzzle

X-RAY

What is happening structurally?

CLINICAL EXAMINATION

What is happening physically?

SYMPTOMS & FUNCTION

How is your knee affecting your life?

Putting these three together gives us a much clearer understanding of your knee than looking at the X-ray alone.

Understand Your X-Ray. Understand Your Knee.

An X-ray is not just a picture.

It is one part of the bigger picture of your knee health.

Know Your Knee Pain to No Pain.

DR MICHAEL LOH

DISCLAIMER

The information shared above includes personal clinical observations and is intended for general health education and knowledge sharing. It does not constitute medical advice or diagnosis. Everyone’s situation is different, so please use this information as a reference rather than applying it to yourself or using it as a basis for treatment. If you have knee pain, please consult an experienced doctor of your choice.